#15 · Create / Concept evaluation

How to judge creative proposals

Anybody can come up with a good idea. But how do you know that an idea is good? There’s no secret formula for success, but here are some ways to determine whether an idea works.

Capture the feeling

A creative concept is supposed to evoke interest. If nobody wants to engage with the message, your effort is in vain. Show the idea to your colleagues and see how they react. What you want is an “aha,” “ha ha” or “ah.” Most of them will give you lots of feedback – listen carefully to what they say. However, judge by their initial reactions. Your potential customers will decide instantly whether to take a closer look or not. They won’t think twice.

Give constructive feedback

Sometimes, you’ll be asked to judge somebody else’s creative proposal. Always trust your gut instinct. If you like what you see, chances are somebody else will like it too. Your gut feeling is knowledge gathered throughout your life readily available. If you don’t like the proposal, explain why. The more precisely you share your thoughts, the more likely you will see a better proposal next time.

Pick what you can stand for

Strong creative concepts break the pattern. They add something new and exciting. They tickle your curiosity beyond the ordinary. On the other hand, strong concepts can be inconvenient both for creatives and decision-makers. Do we dare to present this? Do we dare to run this? Listen to your inner voice. Do you, deep inside, think the concept is great? Are you truly proud of it? If you are, go ahead. If not, don’t do it.

Back to startpage